New York Strip VS Ribeye Steak | A Battle of Beefy Flavors

New York Strip VS Ribeye Steak

If you’re preparing a special occasion lunch, it’s worth spending on the best steak. But, with so many various steak cuts available, how do you know which one is best for you?

The New York strip and ribeye are two of the most expensive steaks served in high-end steakhouses. This guide will assist you in determining what type of steak best meets your preferences or needs.

When deciding between ribeye and a New York strip, remember that there is no wrong option. Both of these steaks are without a doubt worth cooking and tasting.

New York Strip VS Ribeye Steak

At first glance, you might think that New York strip and ribeye steaks are the same thing. Isn’t steak just steak? Certainly not. To make the most of your premium steak cooking experience, we’ll walk you through the key differences between the ribeye and the New York strip.

What Is An NY Strip?

A New York Strip is a classic cut of steak that has been enjoyed since the 1800s. It’s one of the most popular steaks served in restaurants and homes around the world. Cut from the short loin; this steak features thick slices of tender beef with a mild flavor and plenty of marbling for extra juiciness.

Where It Is Located?

The New York Strip is cut from the short loin area along the cow’s spinal column between the rib and sirloin portions. This particular cut of meat generally contains less fat than other steaks, making it perfect for those looking to enjoy its delicious flavors without packing on extra calories.

How To Buy A NY Strip?

When shopping for a New York Strip, there are key tips to remember to ensure you purchase high-quality meat.

First, inspect the marbling throughout the steak – this fat content will ensure it offers a great taste while cooking. Choose steaks with evenly distributed marbling throughout, indicating that they were aged properly before being cut into them. Additionally, choose cuts that are at least 1″ thick – this ensures that you’ll get an even cook on both sides without overcooking it on one side or undercooking it on another.

Preparation/Cooking Tips

When it comes to grilling a perfect New York strip, preparation is key. Whether you’re a seasoned chef or an amateur cook, following these preparation tips can ensure that your steak comes out perfectly cooked every time.

Start by selecting the right cut of meat: look for steaks with even thickness and marbling throughout. Trim off excess fat to reduce flare-ups during the cooking process, then season liberally with salt and pepper. To get that classic steakhouse flavor, let the steak sit at room temperature for 30 minutes before cooking. It helps the steak’s interior reach a uniform temperature, so it cooks when placed on the grill evenly.

Is New York Strip Steak Good?

The New York Strip, also known as a Kansas City Strip or Delmonico Steak, is considered by many to be one of the best cuts of beef. It has great marbling without too much fat and can be cooked quickly on high heat to get that perfect char-grilled taste. It’s also versatile enough to pair with any sauce or seasoning you like, giving you endless possibilities for creating different flavors and textures.

What Is A Ribeye Steak?

Ribeye steak is a popular choice among diners and chefs alike. This tender beef cut from the cow’s rib section has a rich flavor and juicy texture, making it ideal for grilling or broiling. Whether you’re looking to create an indulgent dinner at home or order a steak in a restaurant, ribeye steak is sure to please.

Where It Is Located?

A ribeye steak is cut from the beef’s rib primal between the chuck and loin primal. It contains longissimus dorsi and spinalis dorsi muscles, also known as the “cowboy cut” or tomahawk steak. The muscle fibers in these cuts are relatively short, with abundant marbling giving them an exquisite flavor and tenderness. Furthermore, compared to other steaks such as sirloin or flank steak, Ribeye is typically more expensive due to its higher fat content that boosts flavor and juiciness.

How To Buy A Ribeye Steak?

When buying ribeye steak, it is important to choose wisely. Before making a purchase, consider the following lines. 

First, the grade of the steak should be assessed. Ribeye steaks are available in prime and choice grades. Prime-grade meat will have more marbling and flavor; however, the choice grade may still offer plenty of flavors if cooked correctly.

The cut of the steak is also important when selecting ribeye steak. A boneless cut is generally easier to prepare but can lack flavor compared to bone-in options. The thickness of the steak can vary from 1-3 inches depending on preference, with thicker cuts able to stand up better to high-heat cooking methods such as grilling or searing without becoming too dry or tough.

Preparation/Cooknig Tips

Cooking an amazing ribeye steak isn’t as difficult as it may seem. With the right preparation techniques and cooking methods, you can create a flavorful and juicy steak that will tantalize your taste buds.

The first step to cooking a delicious ribeye steak is to get the best quality meat possible. Look for bright red steaks with some marbling, indicating good fat content. Trim off any excess fat before preparing the steak for cooking—season generously on both sides when ready to cook with salt, pepper, or other dry herbs.

Once seasoned, use one of two popular cooking techniques: pan-searing or grilling. Both methods require preheating the pan or grill to medium-high heat and adding oil before placing the steak.

Comparable Factors Between NY Strip & Ribeye Steak

Though there is much similarity between these two flavorful meat pieces, we can compare these juicy slices with a few important factors like marbling, flavor, cost, etc. So, it seems better to know the difference between a rib eye and NY strip.

  1. Origin/History

The New York Strip is a classic steakhouse staple that has been an enjoyable meat piece for nearly a century. It is also known as the top loin, or shell steak, and was first served in the 1920s at the legendary Delmonico’s restaurant in Manhattan. Executive chef Charles Ranhofer prepared this dish and named it after the city where he was born.

The traces of the early origins of the Ribeye lead us to Scotland and England during the Middle Ages. During this time, the area was known for its abundance of cattle and sheep roaming the countryside. As these animals grazed on grasses, their meat developed more flavorful qualities, making them highly desirable for consumption.

  1. Thickness

The New York Strip boasts an average thickness of one and one-half inches thick, while the Ribeye has an average thickness of two inches. This difference can be noticed in the texture and flavor of each cut, with the thicker Ribeye having a richer marbling that leads to a juicier steak experience overall. The thinner strip steak offers more tenderness and an easier cooking process since it requires less time on the grill or under heat to get that perfect sear.

  1. Marbling

The most obvious difference when comparing these two steaks is that Ribeye has more fatty marbling than the New York strip. It means Ribeye will have a richer flavor and a higher caloric content because of its additional fat. On the other hand, New York strip steak has less fat overall, with prominent streaks running throughout its grainy texture. This added structure gives it a firmer bite while allowing optimal juiciness when cooked properly.

  1. Flavor

The New York Strip is known for its bold flavor and tenderness when cooked properly. The marbling in this cut of steak helps keep it juicy and full-flavored. On the other hand, the Ribeye usually has more fat content than the NY strip, which helps it retain moisture and become incredibly juicy during cooking. 

  1. Nutritional Value

The New York strip is an excellent source of protein, containing 56g per 4-ounce serving. It also contains less fat than the Ribeye; a 4-ounce portion has 8g total fat with 3g saturated fat. The same serving size of ribeye steak provides 11 g of total fat and 5 g of saturated fat. In addition to its slightly lower amounts of fat, the New York strip has more iron than ribeye steak (3 mg vs. 2 mg).

  1. Price

The price of ribeye steaks tends to be higher than that of New York strips due to its marbling, tenderness, and flavor profile. The price can also vary depending on the cut’s size and shape – boneless or bone-in varieties can be found at butcher shops or supermarkets. Generally, though, ribeyes will cost more than New York strips per pound.

FAQs Section New York Strip VS Ribeye Steak

What is the difference between New York strip and Ribeye?

The Ribeye has higher inner marbling or fat, which is the fundamental distinction between these two slices. 

Which is more expensive: Ribeye or New York Strip?

A New York strip, comparable to a Porterhouse steak, will often cost between $10 and $15 per pound, while a ribeye will likely cost nearer to $12 to $16 per pound.

Which is better: Ribeye or New York strip?

The Ribeye is the best choice if you want a delicious steak with a rich, intense taste. The New York Strip is the best option if you want a leaner steak that is still meaty and delicious.

Final Thoughts

The New York Strip and Ribeye steaks are both delicious cuts of beef, but which one is the better choice? After an in-depth analysis of these two steak cuts, the answer depends on what type of flavor and texture you’re looking for. The New York Strip has a bolder taste with less marbling and more chewiness, while the Ribeye has a buttery texture with high marbling. In terms of price, however, the New York Strip is usually cheaper than its counterpart.

Ultimately, there is no definitive answer as to which steak cut trumps the other; it all comes down to personal preference. If you’re looking for something with more flavor and chewiness, then the New York Strip might be your best bet.

Also Check


  • Troy Miller

    Hi! My name is Troy, and I'm the founder of Grill Taster. I have a lot of experience in grilling because I've been testing out products for over a decade. With almost ten years as a professional griller and help to thousands of aspiring BBQ masters, you can trust me to help you find the best grills and accessories on the market so that you don't have to waste time or money on junk. With my family enjoying some summertime fun just outside Carolina, we're all looking forward to your comments and questions!

    View all posts

Similar Posts